Skip to content
Risk and Fraud

The invisible fraud threat: Why synthetic identities are challenging human services programs

Bill Strong  SNAP/TANF Fraud Subject Matter Expert at Thomson Reuters, Retired Chief Investigator

· 8 minute read

Bill Strong  SNAP/TANF Fraud Subject Matter Expert at Thomson Reuters, Retired Chief Investigator

· 8 minute read

Understanding a growing risk to SNAP, TANF, Medicaid, and public assistance programs

Key takeaways
    • Synthetic identities blend real and fake data. They can pass basic validation checks and stay undetected for long periods.
    • Verifying data fields is no longer enough. With so much breached data available, agencies must confirm that a real person exists behind the information.
    • Layered defenses work best. Combining identity intelligence, velocity monitoring, bot detection, and network analytics gives agencies the strongest protection.

This week is International Fraud Awareness Week (aka Fraud Week), an annual global initiative led by the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners (ACFE). Its purpose is to raise awareness about fraud, promote prevention strategies, and encourage organizations and individuals to strengthen antifraud measures. To kick off Fraud Week, I’d like to call attention to synthetic identity fraud in human services programs.

For decades, human services agencies have focused on fraud schemes involving real people. Investigators have traditionally looked for unreported income, duplicate participation, identity theft, household composition misrepresentation, and trafficking activities.

Today, however, a new threat is emerging that is often far more difficult to identify: synthetic identity fraud.

Unlike traditional identity theft, synthetic identity fraud does not rely on stealing a complete identity. Instead, fraudsters create a new identity by combining real and fabricated information. A valid Social Security number may be paired with a fictitious name. A legitimate address may be combined with a manufactured date of birth. Real phone numbers, email addresses, and demographic information are blended together to create an individual who appears legitimate on paper but may not actually exist.

As digital applications, self-service portals, and online benefit management continue to expand, synthetic identities are becoming one of the most significant and least visible risks facing public assistance programs.

The challenge for agencies is no longer simply determining whether information is valid. It’s determining whether a real person exists behind that information.



What is a synthetic identity?

A synthetic identity is an artificially created identity formed by mixing legitimate and fabricated personal information. Examples may include:

    • A valid Social Security number paired with a fictitious name
    • A real address combined with false demographic details
    • Multiple applications tied to the same phone number or email address
    • Identities built using data obtained through prior data breaches
    • Networks of related synthetic identities sharing common attributes

Because portions of the identity are genuine, traditional verification methods may not identify immediate discrepancies. In many cases, synthetic identities can pass basic validation checks and remain undetected for extended periods. Over time, fraudsters may establish transaction histories, digital footprints, and supporting documentation that make these identities appear increasingly legitimate.

Why human services programs are vulnerable

Human services agencies face a difficult balancing act. They must provide timely benefits to eligible households while maintaining strong program integrity controls. Several factors make public assistance programs attractive targets:

Digital-first enrollment. Online applications improve accessibility and efficiency but reduce opportunities for in-person identity verification.

High application volumes. Large caseloads can make manual review of every application impractical, allowing suspicious applications to blend into legitimate workloads.

Multiple program touchpoints. Synthetic identities may interact across SNAP, TANF, Medicaid, child care assistance, energy assistance, workforce programs, and other services, creating opportunities to exploit disconnected systems.

Immediate financial value. Approved benefits often provide rapid access to resources, making public assistance programs attractive targets for organized fraud rings.

The fraud landscape has changed

Large-scale data breaches have fundamentally altered the identity verification challenge. Names, dates of birth, Social Security numbers, phone numbers, email addresses, and histories that once served as strong proof of identity may now be available on underground marketplaces and criminal networks.

As a result, verifying that information matches a database record is no longer enough. Fraudsters don’t need to steal an entire identity. They can leverage pieces of legitimate information, combine them with fabricated details, and create convincing synthetic identities that evade traditional checks.

This has forced agencies to rethink a fundamental question. It’s no longer “Does this information exist?” but “Does this information belong to a real person?”

Why synthetic identities are so difficult to detect

Traditional fraud investigations often identify something that is clearly wrong. A synthetic identity presents a different challenge. The identity may:

    • Pass standard validation rules
    • Have no adverse history
    • Match public records at a basic level
    • Appear unique within agency systems
    • Contain legitimate data elements

In many cases, investigators are not looking for evidence of fraud. They are looking for evidence that a genuine individual exists. That makes synthetic identity fraud one of the most difficult forms of deception to identify, because the fraudster has deliberately created enough truth to make the identity appear legitimate.

Fast transactions, bots, and synthetic identities

Today’s fraud environment extends beyond synthetic identities alone. Criminal organizations frequently combine them with:

    • Automated bot attacks
    • Credential stuffing
    • Stolen consumer data
    • Account takeover attempts
    • Organized fraud networks

These schemes often generate activity at speeds that would be impossible for legitimate program participants. Applications may be submitted rapidly. Contact information may be updated repeatedly. Benefit requests may occur across multiple accounts within minutes. Large volumes of transactions may originate from a common device, IP address, or network.

This is where velocity monitoring becomes critical. Velocity checks help agencies identify:

    • Unusually rapid application submissions
    • High-volume account activity
    • Repeated use of shared identifiers
    • Automated transaction behavior
    • Potential bot-generated activity

Without velocity monitoring, suspicious behaviors that indicate organized fraud may go unnoticed.

Authenticating more than data

Historically, identity verification focused on validating individual pieces of information. Is the Social Security number valid? Does the address exist? Does the date of birth match available records?

These checks remain important, but they no longer provide sufficient protection against synthetic identity fraud. Because breached information is widely available, agencies need multiple layers of security that can distinguish between:

    • Legitimate applicants
    • Stolen identities
    • Synthetic identities
    • Automated bots
    • Organized fraud schemes

The goal is to move beyond validating data fields and toward validating the individual behind the transaction.

Authenticating the completeness of the individual

The most effective defense against synthetic identities is determining whether all identity attributes belong to a single, real-world person. That requires agencies to look beyond isolated data points and evaluate the entire identity ecosystem. Key questions include:

    • Does the identity demonstrate a consistent history over time?
    • Do the identity elements logically connect to one another?
    • Is there evidence of authentic real-world activity?
    • Are there relationships to known fraud networks?
    • Does the behavior align with that of a legitimate applicant?
    • Is a human interacting with the system, or is activity being generated by automation?

By answering these questions, agencies can develop a more complete understanding of identity risk and identify synthetic identities before they can be exploited or cause harm.

The cost of missing synthetic identities

Synthetic identity fraud can have consequences far beyond a single improper payment. Fraudulent identities may be used to:

    • Compromise multiple systems and accounts
    • Support organized fraud rings
    • Enable identity trafficking and resale
    • Breach verification controls and authentication systems
    • Divert resources from legitimate users
    • Erode public trust in government programs

Because synthetic identities can remain active for extended periods, losses may accumulate before agencies recognize the scheme.

The future of program integrity

As human services programs continue to modernize, identity verification must evolve alongside them. Modern program integrity efforts require more than traditional verification checks. They require a combination of:

    • Identity intelligence
    • Digital authentication
    • Velocity monitoring
    • Network analytics
    • Fraud risk scoring
    • Bot detection
    • Investigative tools

Agencies that successfully combat synthetic identity fraud will be those that can establish confidence not only in the information provided but also in the individual behind it.

The future of fraud prevention is no longer about verifying a name, address, or Social Security number in isolation. It’s about verifying the entirety of the individual behind the transaction.

 


 

Access to these tools is limited to authorized, vetted customers. 

Thomson Reuters is not a consumer reporting agency and none of its services or the data contained therein constitute a “consumer report” as such term is defined in the Federal Fair Credit Reporting Act (15 U.S.C. §§ 1681 et seq.) (FCRA). The data provided to you through our products and services may not be used as a factor in consumer debt collection decisioning, establishing a consumer’s eligibility for credit, insurance, employment, housing, government benefits, or for any other purpose authorized under the FCRA. 

 

More answers