In 1958, John Leo Brady was sentenced to death for his role in a murder committed during a robbery. For a time, it appeared as though justice had been served. But there was a problem — the prosecution had suppressed a written statement from an accomplice admitting that while Brady had indeed been a party to the robbery, the accomplice had committed the killing on his own. That statement, had it been introduced during Brady’s trial, could at least have spared Brady the death penalty.
Brady’s appeal made it all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court, and in the 1963 case Brady v. Maryland, it held that in criminal cases, withholding evidence that suggests a defendant is not guilty violates due process “where the evidence is material either to guilt or to punishment.”
Brady himself was eventually paroled from prison in 1974 and, by all accounts, lived a law-abiding life until he died in 2009 at age 76. But his legacy lives on in The Brady Rule — the legal obligation in criminal matters to share all discoverable, material exculpatory evidence with the defense. The rule has been expanded upon and clarified, but ever since Brady v. Maryland, prosecutors who fail to share such evidence risk violating a defendant’s Constitutional rights, as well as their own legal and ethical duties.
While no prosecutor wants to violate The Brady Rule, compliance has become more difficult in the six decades since Brady v. Maryland was handed down. During that time, the sheer volume of evidence has exploded, and treating evidence with the care and diligence it deserves has grown more onerous in an era when it is rare that a prosecutor is given more resources to address it. Discovery may never have been simple; today, it is even less so.
In this white paper, we will explore how and why use of CoCounsel Legal — an AI tool designed by and for attorneys with the kind of safeguards and legal-specific features only Thomson Reuters could create — can make Brady compliance easier and faster.
I. The compliance challenge in today's prosecutor's office
Few prosecutors — and perhaps even fewer of their foils, public defenders — would dispute that within the past few decades, the volume of evidence has ballooned, and has continued to swell at a greater rate in the past 10 years or so. One example is digital communication like text messages, emails, and social media content. These options didn’t exist in 1963 when Brady was on trial. Of course, those forms of evidence exist now — and in staggering quantities. What once might have consisted of a handful of documents can now include thousands of text messages, emails, social media posts, photos, videos, and metadata generated over months or even years.
Prosecutor offices today are managing 80 to 150 active cases per attorney simultaneously, with flat budgets and staffing shortages that show no sign of easing. Up to 74% of government legal departments report staffing shortages, and 71% report increased workloads with no proportional increase in resources, according to an internal Thomson Reuters study. The volume and variety of discovery have not waited for resources to catch up.
The ever-expanding quantity of evidence has increased prosecutors’ workloads and raised several issues. Among them:
- The sheer quantity of discovery materials creates a real risk of inadvertent omission. Omission of evidence, even if it is unintentional, jeopardizes an entire legal strategy and case. With documentation, digital communication, and footage like videos and photographs sprawling across multiple platforms and sources, even diligent legal teams overlook vital information.
- The human burden of manually tracking and verifying full disclosure grows ever greater. With such a volume of evidence, meticulous human effort is needed to process it, categorize it appropriately, and share with opposing counsel or the court as circumstances warrant. The resources allocated to prosecutorial teams has not kept pace, putting further strain on employees who are already strapped.
- Compliance gaps are common and can be costly. Even when inadvertent and identified in a timely manner, they can extend proceedings, demand substantial additional resources to remedy, and expose the organization to a visible and avoidable lapse. When Brady violations become public, the consequences extend beyond the individual case. They erode public trust in the justice system itself.
It is unlikely that the amount of evidence will ever decrease. In fact, many would agree it is only likely to continue its rapid rate of expansion. That means current approaches and resources are not enough to address concerns about inadvertent failure to comply with The Brady Rule in a practical way.
II. The AI parity problem: A growing competitive gap
Lawyers across the profession are increasingly adopting AI tools. That information means prosecutors who have not are falling behind. If opposing counsel can move more quickly and be more organized, it creates a concerning parity gap that does the public a disservice. When only one side has access to those capabilities, it risks creating an imbalance that can affect case preparation, disclosure practices, and ultimately the administration of justice.
This issue is not a hypothetical concern. Federal public defenders already have CoCounsel Legal. Federal courts and the U.S. Supreme Court already have CoCounsel Legal. A growing number of state public defender offices have adopted it as well, not because they had larger budgets, but because they had smaller ones and higher volume pressure. Now that advantage is visible in the courtroom. A prosecutor without CoCounsel Legal is operating against an opponent who can upload a 600-page case file and have AI generate a complete analysis, like witness lists, timeline, inconsistencies, and Brady material, in minutes.
In private practice and public service alike, AI use in the legal industry is enhancing and streamlining work, not replacing the lawyer or legal professional at the center of it all. The right AI solution makes workflows leaner, more efficient, and more comprehensive, trimming away tedious and time-consuming elements of work while freeing lawyers to spend more time and energy on the higher-value portions of the matter where their judgment and experience are necessary. This fact is as true for prosecutors as it is for anyone — AI adoption is not about replacing any human in any way, but rather is about keeping pace.
III. How CoCounsel Legal addresses Brady compliance
CoCounsel Legal was designed specifically for attorneys and is the market’s only AI solution that is built on Westlaw and Practical Law. Unlike consumer-grade AI tools, it has necessary safeguards and specific improvements that make it optimal for use by prosecutors. Engineered to work at the level of a senior associate, CoCounsel Legal performs research, analysis, and drafting together to deliver polished work product, all with a single query. There is no need for prompt engineering or cumbersome toggling back and forth between separate tools.
Prosecutors simply describe the case challenge in plain language — whether it is a charging decision, a discovery review, or a complex multi-agency investigation — and CoCounsel Legal builds the plan, executes each step, and delivers complete work product with citations.
The efficiency gains are concrete and measurable. Discovery review that previously required eight or more hours can be completed in approximately 90 minutes. Grand jury preparation that takes seven to 12 hours manually takes approximately 16 minutes with CoCounsel Legal. Witness lists that require one to two hours to compile manually are generated in under two minutes. Drafting time is reduced by 50% across charging documents, trial briefs, and victim notifications. These figures reflect the real experience of prosecutors already using the platform, according to a Thomson Reuters study.
CoCounsel Legal’s noteworthy features include:
- Complete audit trails for Brady compliance and appellate review. CoCounsel Legal’s work is visible, traceable, and stands up to scrutiny. Each source is linked so the user can click through and verify that is accurate and sound. Every AI decision is logged, reviewable, and defensible, producing the kind of documented disclosure record that satisfies Brady obligations, and withstands appellate scrutiny.
- Authoritative, citation-backed outputs. AI hallucinations could sink a legal case. CoCounsel’s work product is verified and verifiable and protected by intentionally designed safeguards. Every output is grounded in authoritative Westlaw content, not generic internet training data. CoCounsel Legal cannot access the open web or generate fabricated citations. Every case cited is verified by KeyCite, ensuring it remains good law, and every answer includes linked footnotes that prosecutors can verify in seconds.
- Transparent reasoning from start to finish. The reasoning path is visible as CoCounsel Legal works. Prosecutors can see what was planned, what was searched, and what sources actually influenced the result with legal work that office leadership and general counsel can confidently stand behind.
- Government-grade security and data sovereignty. Prosecutors deal with sensitive information that is not always public yet. Nothing that enters CoCounsel Legal is used to train the underlying AI models, ever. Customer data stays contained and is never accessed by Thomson Reuters. CoCounsel Legal is ISO 27001-certified, SOC 2 Type II-compliant, FedRAMP In Process with HHS sponsorship, and end-to-end encrypted to meet the security standards government legal offices require.
- Workspaces to store material in one place. CoCounsel Legal’s dedicated workspaces keep everything — documents, templates, resources consulted — in one place. Individual users can easily pick up where they left off, and teams can be sure they are working from the same page and collaborating smoothly and easily. Whether for a single prosecutor or for an entire team, the efficiency gains here are hard to overstate. Prior opinions, prior positions, and office templates shape the analysis from the first prompt so the ultimate work product reflects how the office actually practices.
- Human-in-the-loop design. With CoCounsel Legal, AI assists — but the attorney decides. Any prosecutor who uses it will always be in the driver’s seat. While CoCounsel Legal is engineered to function at the level of a senior associate, it also keeps humans in control. Every output includes footnotes so prosecutors can verify every citation and every claim. CoCounsel Legal shifts attorney time toward analysis and strategy, not away from it.
In sum, CoCounsel Legal makes work easier and more efficient. In doing so, it makes it far less likely that prosecutors will miss something, even when the volume of evidence is great, and jeopardize Brady compliance.
IV. What Brady compliance looks like in practice with CoCounsel Legal
To make this concrete, here is how a Brady compliance and discovery review workflow operates within CoCounsel Legal:
A prosecutor uploads the full discovery production, like police reports, witness statements, forensic reports, and body cam transcripts, into a CoCounsel Legal workspace dedicated to that matter. Using plain language, they prompt the system, such as, "Identify any exculpatory evidence or Brady material. Find inconsistencies in witness statements. Locate evidence contradicting the prosecution theory. Identify credibility issues with witnesses or officers."
CoCounsel Legal executes each step automatically, generating a timeline of events across all sources to surface discrepancies, flagging potentially exculpatory evidence with citations to the exact document language where it appears, and producing a Brady disclosure memo with a complete audit trail. That audit trail documents what was analyzed, when, and by whom, giving the office a defensible record of its constitutional diligence if disclosure is ever challenged.
What previously required eight or more hours of manual review is completed in approximately 90 minutes, with greater consistency and a documented record that manual review cannot produce.
V. Discovery questions to ask your current AI tool
If your office is already using an AI product for discovery, it is important to assess it rigorously to determine whether it is the best tool for you.
To do so, some good questions to ask would be:
- Does it provide a complete audit trail for Brady compliance? CoCounsel Legal does. If your current tool does not, then you are working harder when you could be working smarter.
- Can outputs be traced back to authoritative sources via citations? Prosecutors cannot trust something they cannot verify. CoCounsel Legal solves that problem with linked, traceable citations to trusted authorities.
- Is it built with the security standards required for sensitive government data? Data security is non-negotiable. There should be no doubt in your mind that your vendor’s product treats your material confidentially and safely — the way CoCounsel Legal does.
- How does it handle inaccurate or hallucinated content? Hallucinations, or made-up answers that sound reasonable on first glance, were a major reason lawyers were hesitant to embrace AI. If the AI tool your office uses for discovery introduces any risk of hallucinations, then it is working against you. CoCounsel Legal is grounded exclusively in authoritative Westlaw content and cannot access the open web, eliminating the hallucination risk that has led to attorney sanctions in other contexts.
- Does it show its reasoning? A tool that produces a result without showing how it got there is a tool you cannot fully trust or defend. CoCounsel Legal makes every step of its reasoning visible and every source verifiable.
Because CoCounsel Legal was engineered specifically for the legal profession, it is unlikely your current AI tool — if your office even has one — can stack up.
VI. Conclusion: Compliance confidence at scale
Prosecutors who adopt the right AI tools can reduce compliance risk while increasing efficiency. The goal is not just meeting the Brady standard — it is building an office-wide culture of defensible, documented disclosure. CoCounsel Legal helps legal teams identify relevant evidence more consistently, organize massive volumes of discovery materials, and create standardized workflows that reduce the likelihood of critical information being missed. Rather than replacing prosecutorial judgment, CoCounsel Legal supports it by organizing workflows, streamlining tasks, and increasing efficiency and speed. As discovery volumes continue to grow, CoCounsel Legal gives prosecutors the tools to demonstrate that they have taken reasonable, systematic steps to meet their constitutional obligations while strengthening public confidence.
CoCounsel Legal is purpose-built for attorneys. Describe your case challenge in plain language — research, analysis, drafting, and a complete Brady-compliant audit trail follow. See CoCounsel Legal in action today and take a guided tour.